Sally Field Tova Sullivan Lewis Pullman Cameron Cassmore Colm Meaney Ethan Mack Joan Chen Janice Kim Kathy Baker Mary Ann Minetti Beth Grant Barb Vanderhoof Sofia Black-D'Elia Avery Brandon McEwan Teenage Erik Donald Sales Terry Mapuana Makia Jessica Snell Laura Harris Andie Anthony Harrison Sheriff Dan Payne Adam Wright Shauna Johannesen Eliza Wright Chris William Martin Simon Brinks Alfred Molina Marcellus (voice) David Parent Police Officer Michael Delleva Tanner Duncan Fraser Ex-Cop Kareem Malcolm Host Sally Field Tova Sullivan Lewis Pullman Cameron Cassmore Colm Meaney Ethan Mack Joan Chen Janice Kim Kathy Baker Mary Ann Minetti Beth Grant Barb Vanderhoof Sofia Black-D'Elia Avery Brandon McEwan Teenage Erik Donald Sales Terry Mapuana Makia Jessica Snell Laura Harris Andie Anthony Harrison Sheriff Dan Payne Adam Wright Shauna Johannesen Eliza Wright Chris William Martin Simon Brinks Alfred Molina Marcellus (voice) David Parent Police Officer Michael Delleva Tanner Duncan Fraser Ex-Cop Kareem Malcolm Host Andres Joseph Brad Katie Findlay Liz Arielle Tuliao Field Trip Teacher Sasha Williams Mother Michael Karl Richards Will Miles Marthaller 5/6 Year Old Erik Meghan Heffern Young Tova Michael Adamthwaite Fisherman Tim Howe Man on Keyboard Sally Field Tova Sullivan Lewis Pullman Cameron Cassmore Colm Meaney Ethan Mack Joan Chen Janice Kim Kathy Baker Mary Ann Minetti Beth Grant Barb Vanderhoof Sofia Black-D'Elia Avery Brandon McEwan Teenage Erik Donald Sales Terry Mapuana Makia Jessica Snell Laura Harris Andie Anthony Harrison Sheriff Dan Payne Adam Wright Shauna Johannesen Eliza Wright Chris William Martin Simon Brinks Alfred Molina Marcellus (voice) David Parent Police Officer Michael Delleva Tanner Duncan Fraser Ex-Cop Kareem Malcolm Host Andres Joseph Brad Katie Findlay Liz Arielle Tuliao Field Trip Teacher Sasha Williams Mother Michael Karl Richards Will Miles Marthaller 5/6 Year Old Erik Meghan Heffern Young Tova Michael Adamthwaite Fisherman Tim Howe Man on Keyboard